First thing you should have done is visually compared the replacement parts to the originals to confirm they are the correct ones.
Also confirm what you received was what you actually ordered, not uncommon that a mistake is made when your order was pulled and there is a mix up.
Yes, order up another replacement.
Double check that it is for your specific make and model.
You can also check other sites using the MOOG p/n to confirm it is the part for your car.
And before you commit to the install make sure it fits with out a struggle.
If it doesn’t you can return it and try to get another MFG replacement.