Definitely keep the RAV4!!! I am not a fan of the acadias at all. Yes they can be very luxurious and comfy inside, but they just don’t hold up overtime. Interesting story about that, my uncle leased a 2015 Acadia previously and he knew the sales manager and he asked the guy if it was a good car to buy off lease since his 2004 Highlander has been a fantastic car, and the manager said “read between the lines”. Needless to say, he got the picture. The rav4 is an excellent vehicle that will last a very long time.